Skip to main content

OCR’s own letters

HHS Office for Civil Rights: 13 selected complaint records, 2023–2025

This table covers 13 selected OCR complaint numbers in the reviewed August 2023–September 2025 records. OCR's letters give an outcome for 11 of them, and none of those 11 reports an investigation or a finding. In OCR's own words, 3 were closed without investigation, 3 were outside OCR's authority, 3 were directed to another agency (the U.S. Justice Department, the Connecticut Attorney General and the HHS Office of Inspector General), and 2 were folded into another complaint number. Those 3 letters point David to the other office; they do not show that OCR sent the complaint there itself. For the other 2, OCR's latest message in the records reviewed came through an encrypted mail service, and no outcome has been confirmed.

· 13 complaint numbers · 3 closed without investigation · 3 outside OCR's authority · 3 directed to another agency · 2 folded into another complaint number · 2 no outcome found

How these selected records connect to the 2026 CMS communications remand

This table covers 13 selected OCR complaint numbers from August 2023 through September 2025. A separate complaint against the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) was remanded to a field office in January 2026. The table is not the complete OCR history.

Under OCR transactions 25-614156 and 26-669246, an investigator requested information about communication modifications concerning CMS FOIA 110620247022 on April 17, 2026. David answered on April 24. On April 27 OCR acknowledged that it had the information needed to proceed with the remanded investigation.

These records establish that historical investigation step. They do not establish a finding of discrimination, a completed investigation or its present status. They do not establish that the separate remand controls are the same complaints as any row in this table.

Read the separately dated OCR remand account and preserved April 17 source. The source-reading pages also distinguish the September 25, 2025 consolidation from the earlier, undated determination transmitted May 29, 2024.

How to read this table

Each row is one OCR complaint (transaction) number. 'OCR's answer' quotes OCR's letter where the letter was re-read for this page; rows marked 'summary' describe a letter that was reviewed in full but is not quoted here.

The 13 complaint numbers

Complaint numberReceivedOutcome dateWhat OCR didOCR’s answer
01-23-535217August 2023 (OCR wrote that the U.S. Justice Department had referred David's complaint about the Connecticut Department of Social Services to OCR)—No outcome foundOn August 14, 2023 OCR asked for David's signed consent and more details. On September 1, 2023 OCR wrote that the complaint was still under review. OCR's next message (September 5, 2023) came through an encrypted mail service; its text is not in David's records.
01-23-540572August 2023—No outcome foundOCR's message of August 18, 2023 came through an encrypted mail service; its text is not in David's records.
01-23-543878September 1, 2023 (a complaint about the care given to a person in the Connecticut ABI waiver program)September 21, 2023Closed without investigationSummary of OCR's letter: OCR treated the complaint as a medical quality-of-care concern outside what it handles, closed it without further investigation, and pointed to state licensing and other routes.
01-23-5477322023October 5, 2023Directed to another agency (U.S. Justice Department)"Based upon our review of your complaint, we have determined that the concerns you raise are more appropriately addressed by the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”)." Signed by Regional Manager Susan M. Pezzullo Rhodes.
01-24-551819November 2023January 5, 2024Closed without investigation"We have reviewed your complaint and have determined that OCR will not investigate your allegations. Therefore, OCR is closing this complaint with no further action, effective the date of this letter." Signed by Susan M. Pezzullo Rhodes. Record card
01-24-554014November 16, 2023January 9, 2024Folded into another complaint numberClosed "without further investigation" and "incorporated into OCR Transaction Number 01-23-551819", which OCR called "another open complaint you filed where OCR is reviewing similar allegations." Signed by Susan M. Pezzullo Rhodes. Record card
01-24-554271November 24, 2023 ("systemic rights violations within the state of Connecticut")March 14, 2024Outside OCR's authority"we have determined that OCR does not have authority to investigate your civil rights complaint because you have not alleged a claim of prohibited discrimination under one of the civil rights laws OCR enforces." Signed by Susan M. Pezzullo Rhodes.
01-24-556884December 15, 2023 (a whistleblower complaint against the Connecticut Department of Social Services)January 18, 2024Directed to another agency (Connecticut Attorney General)Summary of OCR's letter: OCR determined that the concerns were more appropriately addressed by the Connecticut Attorney General and gave that office's complaint route. The letter does not show that OCR sent the complaint there itself.
01-24-556944December 18, 2023 (systemic rights violations by the Connecticut Department of Social Services and whistleblower protections)May 29, 2024
Transmittal email date. The retained determination letter has no printed letter date.
Outside OCR's authority"we have determined that OCR does not have authority to investigate your civil rights complaint because you have not established a claim of prohibited discrimination. As such, we regret to inform you that the Office for Civil Rights cannot accept your complaint." Signed by Susan M. Pezzullo Rhodes. Selected letter excerpt
01-25-592844October 9, 2024 (a complaint against HHS)November 15, 2024Outside OCR's authorityOCR's investigator wrote that the earlier determination found no OCR jurisdiction and that there was no basis for reconsideration. (Already covered on this site.)
01-25-597746October 10, 2024 (a complaint that the Connecticut Medicaid ABI Waiver Program is mismanaging federal Medicaid funds)December 20, 2024Directed to another agency (HHS Office of Inspector General)"Based upon our review of your complaint, we have determined that the concerns you raise are more appropriately addressed by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”), Office of Inspector General (“OIG”)." OCR gave the link to the OIG Hotline. The letter does not show that OCR sent the complaint to OIG itself. Signed by Regional Manager Barbara Stampul. Edited excerpt of the letter
01-25-595812not stated in the letterFebruary 7, 2025Closed without investigation"After conducting such a review of your complaint, OCR determined not to further investigate the allegations you raised. Based on the foregoing, OCR is closing this case without further investigation, effective the date of this letter." Signed for Regional Manager Barbara C. Stampul.
CU 25 6332302025September 25, 2025Folded into another complaint numberConsolidated into complaint 24 556944. The earlier determination is undated and was transmitted May 29, 2024; the consolidation letter is dated September 25, 2025. Record card Selected letter excerpt

Three letters that pointed David to another office

Three OCR letters directed David to another office’s complaint route. On October 5, 2023, OCR said the concerns in 01-23-547732 were more appropriately addressed by DOJ and provided information on filing a DOJ complaint. On January 18, 2024, OCR directed him to the Connecticut Attorney General’s complaint route for 01-24-556884. On December 20, 2024, OCR said the concerns in 01-25-597746 were more appropriately addressed by the HHS Office of Inspector General and gave the OIG Hotline link. None of the three letters shows that OCR itself sent a complaint or its attachments, or that any receiving office accepted or acted on them.

DOJ and OCR pointed to each other

The Justice Department and OCR pointed to each other. In August 2023 OCR wrote that DOJ had referred one of David's complaints to OCR (01-23-535217). In October 2023 OCR wrote that another complaint was "more appropriately addressed" by DOJ (01-23-547732). DOJ's own released records show every one of David's 46 DOJ civil rights reports marked CLOSED (see DOJ’s records table). DOJ's referral to OCR and OCR's later advice to contact DOJ concern different complaint numbers. They do not show that the same complaint or evidence went back and forth.

What these records do not show

  • What OCR's encrypted messages about 01-23-535217 and 01-23-540572 said.
  • Whether OCR or the Connecticut Attorney General ever acted on the complaint OCR pointed there.
  • Whether OCR forwarded 01-25-597746 to HHS-OIG, or whether OIG received or acted on it.
  • Whether 01-23-551819 and 01-24-551819 are the same complaint.
  • Whether the allegations are true. A complaint is not a finding.

Why the OCR letters are not posted

OCR's letters show David's private contact details, so the letters themselves are not posted. For 01-25-597746, an edited excerpt without contact details is linked. Investigators' names are left out; the Regional Managers who signed the letters are named.

Independent public-records archive. Verify independently. Related: HHS OCR, January 2024 · HHS OCR complaint 633230, 2025. Copied from OCR’s letters; checked November 17, 2026.