PDF text version
FOIA request 176186 to Ct Freedom Of Information Agency: citizens-guide-10-19-21.pdf
Text extracted from the PDF so it can be read and searched. The PDF is the record.
- The PDF
- Open the PDF (attachment.pdf)
- Size
- 164,067 bytes (160.2 KB)
- SHA-256
93eca9290d962906b7666c4eeb8724a875fb7af57ebd5f78f6c69ca2a62f1bdb- Pages
- 6 pages; text layer on all of them
Record pages that link to this PDF
Text, page by page
Page 1 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 1 of 6
I. IN GENERAL.
The Freedom of Information Commission was created by the General Assembly in l975 with the
passage of the Freedom of Information Act. The Act provides the public with rights of access to
records and meetings of public agencies. You may obtain a copy of the Act without charge by
contacting the Commission at the address printed on the last page of this guide.
If you feel that you have been denied a right guaranteed by the Freedom of Information Act you
may file an appeal with the Freedom of Information Commission.
II. REQUIREMENTS FOR FILING AN APPEAL.
Generally, an appeal must be filed with the Commission within 30 days of the violation alleged,
except when the appeal concerns an unnoticed or secret meeting. In that case, the appeal must be
filed within 30 days after the person filing the appeal receives notice in fact that such meeting
was held. There is no specific form to complete. A letter containing a statement of all relevant
facts is sufficient to institute an appeal. In addition, if you want to request the imposition of a
civil penalty (fine) permitted under Section 1-206(b) of the Act, you should say so explicitly in
your letter. Your letter should contain the names, titles and addresses, if known, of the persons
or agencies you feel have violated the Act, as well as a telephone number at which you can be
reached during business hours. If an appeal concerns a request for records contained in a public
employee's personnel, medical file or similar file, the Commission may require the respondent
public agency to notify the subject employee(s) of the appeal and any such employee(s) may
intervene as a party to the appeal.
NOTE: BE SURE TO READ THE ACT CAREFULLY TO DETERMINE WHETHER YOUR
CLAIM OF A VIOLATION IS SUPPORTED BY THE LAW. The staff of the Freedom of
Information Commission is available to assist you with any procedural questions concerning an
appeal. While the staff may be able to refer you to specific sections of the law and cases
interpreting them, only the Commission, not its staff, has the power to interpret and apply the
law.
III. PRE-HEARING CONSIDERATIONS.
A person bringing an appeal to the Commission is called the "complainant" and the public
agency or official defending is called the "respondent." When an appeal is filed, the Commission
issues a "Notice of Hearing and Order to Show Cause." This is the official notice that the matter
will be heard, and sets forth the date, time and place of the hearing. All parties named must
appear at the hearing, either in person or by counsel or other authorized representative. A
complainant's failure to appear will lead to dismissal of the complaint. A respondent's failure to
appear deprives it of the opportunity to defend itself against the complainant's allegations.
The Freedom of Information Commission has an "ombudsman" program which involves the
assigning of a staff member to each appeal to act as liaison between the parties. An ombudsman
Page 2 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 2 of 6
will attempt to effect a settlement of each appeal. But if a settlement is not possible, the matter
will proceed to a hearing.
Due to the large number of cases filed and the requirements for speedy action, the Freedom of
Information Commission will NOT ordinarily postpone scheduled hearings at the request of the
parties UNLESS the parties are negotiating a settlement and, in writing, request a postponement
based upon the likelihood of agreement. For the same reason, hearings are scheduled to be heard
within 90 MINUTE time periods. Be prompt to ensure that you will be able to take advantage of
the full 90 minutes allotted.
The hearings are conducted in one of the hearing rooms on the FIRST FLOOR at 18-20 Trinity
Street, Hartford. There is no off-street parking available, so be prepared to arrive early enough
to find a parking space, either on the surrounding streets where parking is metered, or in
commercial lots in the vicinity. If you are attending an afternoon hearing, be aware of tow
zones--they are enforced PROMPTLY at 4:00 p.m.
IV. PREPARING FOR A HEARING.
Here are a few suggestions on how to prepare for a Freedom of Information Commission
hearing.
1. Know your facts. Don't rely on what others have told you or what you have read in the
newspaper. Check the facts yourself if possible.
2. Determine what evidence you need to prove your case. That is, consider what you would
want proved if you were a member of the Freedom of Information
3. Commission. Remember, however, you may present evidence only on those issues fairly
raised in your appeal. Decide what documents and witnesses you will need. For
example, if you have alleged that an agency's agenda was faulty, bring a copy of the
agenda with you.
4. Make arrangements in advance to have NECESSARY witnesses and documents available
for the hearing. You may wish to contact the opposing party or its counsel, either directly
or through the ombudsman assigned to your appeal, to see if you can agree upon essential
facts. You may avoid the necessity of presenting evidence by “stipulating” or agreeing to
these facts at the hearing. See Section V. of this Guide concerning the procedure for
entering agreements of fact on the record.
5. If a NECESSARY witness will not testify voluntarily, contact the Commission staff
immediately. If you are able to show why the person's testimony is necessary and why
you believe he or she will not appear voluntarily, the Commission may issue a subpoena
which would require the person to appear. You must make arrangements for and pay the
cost of serving such a subpoena.
V. CONDUCT OF A HEARING.
One of the five members of the Freedom of Information Commission or a staff member is
designated to preside over the hearing and is called the "Hearing Officer." The Hearing Officer
Page 3 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 3 of 6
is usually assisted by a staff attorney, one of whose functions is to answer procedural
questions. The hearing is an official proceeding conducted as a contested case under Chapter 54
of the Connecticut General Statutes and the Regulations of the Commission. The Commission,
however, strives to maintain an atmosphere comfortable to those parties not represented by an
attorney. Procedures are explained and questions answered so that lay people can understand
what will happen and what is expected of them. A copy of the Commission's Regulations may
be obtained upon request at the address printed on the last page or can be found starting with
Section l-2lj-l of the Regulations of Connecticut State Agencies.
Each hearing consists of a presentation of evidence, first by the complainant, then by the
respondent. The hearing will provide the ONLY opportunity to present evidence, and all
evidence becomes part of the record of the hearing. Each party may testify, examine and cross-
examine witnesses and offer documents as evidence. The presentation of evidence is followed
by a brief argument on the law.
Hearings will ordinarily follow this format: The Hearing Officer convenes the hearing and
outlines the hearing procedures, explaining how the Commission will arrive at its decision in the
case. The parties are asked if they are willing to go "off the record" (that is, the tape recorder is
turned off) to discuss whether any facts can be agreed upon without the need to present
evidence. These are called "stipulations." Although the conference concerning stipulations is off
the record, the hearing is still open to the public. If the parties wish to discuss any matter
privately, they may request a recess and leave the hearing room for their discussion. After the
informal conference is completed, the hearing proceeds on the record (that is, the tape recorder is
turned back on). The facts agreed upon are read into the tape recorder and become part of the
record of the hearing. If there is need for further evidence, all witnesses are then sworn in.
a. Presenting evidence.
The complainant should fairly raise the allegations made in the complaint. (See Section IV. of
the Guide concerning preparation for a hearing). This may be accomplished by the testimony of
witnesses (including the complainant) or by the submission of written evidence. If a party is not
represented by a lawyer or other authorized representative, that party may testify in narrative
form--that is, by reciting facts without being asked a question. All other witnesses should testify
in a question-and-answer format but narrative maybe allowed.
Evidence should relate specifically to the case in question, and should reflect what the witness
KNOWS, as opposed to what the witness was told or guesses or suspects. When a document is
offered into evidence, a witness may be necessary to testify as to its authenticity and how it was
obtained. Don't waste time on a long recitation of prior events not related directly to the claimed
violation of the Freedom of Information Act.
Each witness is subject to cross-examination based upon the testimony given. The party
introducing the witness then may re-examine the witness in order to clarify or explain testimony
brought forth on cross-examination. This is called "re-direct," and is occasionally followed by
Page 4 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 4 of 6
"re-cross examination." This process allows the parties to satisfy themselves that each witness
has presented fairly all material facts.
After the complainant has completed the presentation of evidence, the respondent is then given
the same opportunity to present additional evidence in defense. The respondent, unless it has
evidence that it is not a public agency, must prove that the actions at issue were proper under the
Freedom of Information Act. If the complaint specifically seeks the imposition of the civil
penalty permitted under Section 1-206(b) of the Act, the respondent also should be prepared to
show that the alleged denial of any rights under the Freedom of Information Act was based upon
reasonable grounds. If necessary, the complainant is given the opportunity to present further
evidence in rebuttal.
Remember: Do not present several witnesses to testify to the same facts (cumulative testimony)-
-it is not necessary nor is it desirable. Also keep in mind that a party's motivation in pursuing
rights under the Freedom of Information Act is not relevant and will not have any impact on the
Commission's decision.
b. Argument on the Law.
Once all the evidence has been submitted, the parties are allowed to make a brief argument on
the law. This argument should state why you believe that the Freedom of Information Act was
or was not violated. Don't repeat all of the evidence presented or quote extensively from the Act
itself. Written arguments and briefs may be filed at the hearing or within the time specified by
the Hearing Officer, but are not required. A copy of any written argument or brief must be given
or mailed to all parties of record and the written argument or brief must contain a statement to
this effect.
VI. HEARING OFFICER'S REPORT.
After the hearing is concluded, the Hearing Officer prepares a report for the full Commission's
consideration. This report consists of a series of findings of fact, conclusions of law, and a
recommended order. The report is based SOLELY upon the record of the hearing and the
Hearing Officer's application of the law.
Even if the complaint does not specifically seek the imposition of the civil penalty permitted
under Section 1-206(b) of the Act, the Hearing Officer may find that specific violations of the
Act appear to have been committed without reasonable grounds. In that case, the report may
recommend that a subsequent hearing be held in order to afford the respondent an opportunity to
show that any such violation was based upon reasonable grounds.
The report is not a final decision, and must be adopted by the Freedom of Information
Commission to become one. All parties will receive a copy of the report, as well as notice of the
date, time and place of the meeting at which the Commission will consider and vote on it. If you
wish to submit a brief or written argument to the full Commission, an original and the number of
copies indicated on the transmittal letter should be in the Commission's office no later than the
Page 5 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 5 of 6
date stated on the transmittal letter. A copy of any written argument or brief must be mailed to
all parties of record and the written statement or brief must contain a statement to this
effect. Typically, Commission decisions are scheduled for action at its regular meetings, held on
the second and fourth Wednesdays of each month.
VII. COMMISSION ACTION ON HEARING OFFICER'S REPORT.
Before the Hearing Officer's Report becomes the final decision of the Freedom of Information
Commission, it must be approved by the Commission itself. The Commission may approve the
report, amend the report, and approve it as amended, or it may reject the report completely.
The parties may attend the meeting at which the report is considered and may offer brief oral
arguments (maximum of 10 MINUTES per side) opposing or in favor of the report. NO NEW
OR ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE WILL BE ENTERTAINED AT THE MEETING.
Each party is advised to attend the Commission's meeting at which the Hearing Officer's Report
will be considered and voted upon, even if the report is in its favor. Remember, all opposing
parties may attend the meeting, and the Commission may be persuaded to amend or reject the
Hearing Officer's Report. If a party is not present, it risks that unrebutted or unchallenged
arguments may convince the Commission to take an unfavorable action in adopting its Final
Decision.
After arguments are concluded, the Commission deliberates and votes in public session as to
whether to approve, amend or reject the Hearing Officer's Report. All parties are sent a copy of
the Commission's final decision.
VIII. APPEALS FROM COMMISSION DECISIONS.
The law provides that an aggrieved party may appeal a final decision of the Freedom of
Information Commission to the Superior Court.
If you are successful at the Commission level and an appeal to the courts is brought by an
aggrieved (unsuccessful) party, you will be served with a copy of that appeal. Counsel for the
Commission will participate in the appeal on behalf of the Commission, but will NOT act as
your personal representative. Because your interests may not always be identical to that of the
Commission, you may choose to consult your own attorney to fully protect your rights.
IX. MISCELLANEOUS.
If you should resolve your dispute before the Commission hearing is held, please notify the
Commission IMMEDIATELY so that everyone concerned can be informed. The appeal to the
Commission will be withdrawn officially upon receipt of a written communication, signed by the
complainant, stating that the matter has been resolved. If written communication is not received
Page 6 of 6
State of Connecticut
Freedom of Information Commission
Citizen’s Guide
Page 6 of 6
withdrawing the appeal and the complainant does not appear at the hearing, the case will be
dismissed.
If an appeal concerns an announced agency decision to meet in executive session, or an ongoing
agency practice of meeting in executive sessions, for a stated purpose, if practicable the
Commission will hold a preliminary hearing within 72 hours of the filing of the appeal. The
purpose of the preliminary hearing is to determine whether there is probable cause to believe that
the agency decision or practice violates the Freedom of Information Act. If the Hearing Officer
finds such probable cause, the agency will be prohibited from meeting in executive session for
that purpose until the Commission finally decides the appeal. The Commission's final decision is
due within five days of the preliminary decision finding probable cause.
A Hearing Officer's Report is a public record, available to the public (including the press) as
soon as it is submitted by the Hearing Officer. Therefore, you may read about a proposed
decision before receiving your own copy.
If you wish to contact the Commission, you may do so at the following address and telephone
number:
Freedom of Information Commission
165 Capitol Ave, Suite 1100
Hartford, Connecticut 06106
Telephone: 1 866 374-3617 or (860) 566-5682;
Fax: (860) 566-6474
Email: foi@ct.gov
Website: http://www.portal.ct.gov/foi
About this page
This page shows the text layer of the PDF, page by page, as the PDF stores it. Anything blacked out or masked in the PDF stays hidden here, and masks such as XXXX are kept as they are. No text was added or corrected. Pages that are only a scanned image have no text layer; their text was not extracted.
All PDF text pages: PDF text versions.