January to April 2026: CMS recalls and revises its January 22 letter; two different CMS answers on March 13
Quoted from CMS emails to David. Office mailbox addresses and phone numbers are left out. Both January versions say: “This correspondence does not constitute a determination regarding any specific allegation or compliance finding.”
- From
- CMS, Division of Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) correspondence mailbox; CMS Boston Regional Office (Chris Thibault); CMS New York Regional Office
- To
- David Medeiros
- Dates
- January 22, January 23, March 13 and April 7, 2026
- Subjects
- “CMS Response - Medeiros” (January); “CMS Response - ABI” (April 7)
Order of events
- January 22, 2026, 23:40 UTC: CMS HCBS sends “CMS Response - Medeiros.”
- January 23, 2026, 13:10 UTC: two recall notices: “CMS DHCBSOOCORRESP would like to recall the message, “CMS Response - Medeiros”.”
- January 23, 2026, 23:22 UTC: a revised letter with the same subject.
- March 13, 2026, 15:36 UTC: CMS HCBS letter (quoted below).
- March 13, 2026, 18:05 UTC: the CMS New York office: “We received four more inquires. I will enter as a duplicate in SWIFT.” (“inquires” is spelled that way in the original.)
- March 13, 2026, 18:48 UTC: CMS Boston Regional Office (quoted below), copied to the House Oversight and Senate Finance committee addresses.
- April 7, 2026: CMS HCBS letter (quoted below).
Every wording change from January 22 to January 23
Found by a word-by-word comparison of the two letters. The rest of both letters is the same.
| # | January 22 original | January 23 revision |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | “This letter is in response to your most recent correspondence” | “This is a response to your most recent correspondence” (double space as sent) |
| 2 | “The Office of Human Rights (OCR) is the agency within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)” | “The Office of Civil Rights (OCR) is the agency within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)” |
| 3 | “we encourage you to file a complaint with OCR (https://www.hhs.gov/civil-rights/filing-a-complaint/index.html).” | “we encourage you to file a complaint with OCR here: (https://www.hhs.gov/civil-rights/filing-a-complaint/index.html).” |
| 4 | “Compliance with COI standards is a requirement for all HCBS waiver programs.” | “Compliance with COI is a requirement for all HCBS waiver programs. Consistent with those requirements, the provider that develops the person-centered service plan cannot be the same as one delivering services to that individual.” |
| 5 | “CMS does not select providers nor vet providers; rather, states establish provider enrollment and participation processes consistent with their approved waiver authority and state procurement or enrollment policies. States must ensure that beneficiaries have freedom of choice among qualified providers and that provider selection processes are administered in a non-discriminatory manner. Participation in a waiver program is contingent upon meeting state-defined requirements and maintaining compliance with all applicable federal and state standards.” | “CMS does not select qualified Medicaid providers for each service. We work with states to consider qualifications and ensure provider enrollment and participation meet the needs of those to be served consistent with their approved waiver authority and state procurement or provider enrollment policies. States must ensure that beneficiaries have freedom of choice among qualified providers and sharing a list of qualified providers that can be selected is a way to address this. Additionally, if a participant directs their own services, they may identify providers of their choosing. Provider participation in a waiver program is contingent upon meeting state-defined requirements and maintaining compliance with all applicable federal and state standards.” |
March 13, 2026: two answers on the same day
CMS HCBS office, 15:36 UTC:
“We are currently reviewing the issues outlined in your letter, including concerns related to care-management capacity, service coordination, and compliance with applicable federal and state requirements.”
“we want to assure you that your concern has been fully reviewed and resolved on our end as outlined in previous correspondence.”
“CMS considers this matter closed, but should you experience a new or different issue, please don’t hesitate to reach out and we will be happy to assist.”
CMS Boston Regional Office, Chris Thibault, 18:48 UTC:
“I apologize for the confusion, your case is currently being reviewed by the CMS Center for Medicaid & CHIP Services.”
“Since this concerns the Connecticut Medicaid program, the CMS Boston Regional Office should be your point of contact going forward. The other regional offices have closed these inquiries as duplicates because they do not cover Connecticut. Your case has not been closed and is currently still being reviewed.”
April 7, 2026
“Your concerns have been assessed by multiple CMS team members given their complexity. While we understand that you may not be in agreement with CMS’s determinations, we strongly encourage you to continue to engage with the Connecticut Department of Social Services”
“Please note that all communications from CMS will be provided in writing, using clear and accessible language. Should you require additional time to respond to any correspondence, do not hesitate to inform us.”
What this shows, and what it does not
- Shows: CMS recalled and rewrote its January 22 letter within a day. The revision added the conflict-of-interest rule (the plan writer cannot also deliver the services) and removed “nor vet providers” and the “non-discriminatory manner” sentence.
- Shows: on March 13, two CMS offices gave opposite status statements: “closed” and “has not been closed.”
- Does not show any CMS finding against Connecticut or anyone else. Both January versions say they are not a determination.
- Does not show why the January wording was changed, or which March 13 statement controls today.
- No document explaining “CMS’s determinations” in the April 7 letter was found.
Not found: any Boston or Center for Medicaid & CHIP Services status after March 13, 2026, and the SWIFT tracking numbers. Holders: the CMS Boston Regional Office and the CMS Center for Medicaid & CHIP Services.
Part of the source records behind Warnings and Answers and the Early Warning Record. A receipt, a forward or an acknowledgment shows that an office got something; it is not proof of an investigation or a finding. A decision by an office is that office’s decision, not a court ruling.