November 7, 2018: ABI Resources' reply to DSS, "Re: Mindscape ABI clients"
Privacy-cleaned copy of an original record cited in the Early Warning Record entry for November 6-7, 2018.
- Date
- November 7, 2018, 11:21 AM (Eastern)
- From
- David Medeiros, CBIS, ABI Resources
- To
- Kathy Bruni, Director, DSS Community Options Unit
- Copied
- George Chamberlin, Amy Dumont, Beth Carangelo (DSS); Commissioner Roderick Bremby; DSS Office of Legal Counsel
- Subject
- Re: Mindscape ABI clients
Good Morning Kathy Bruni and Department of Social Services,
We are pleased that you reached out to us as we would like to convey some concerning information. We were recently contacted by a very upset family that was referred to the Supported Living Group without any choice in the matter by a CCCi case manager. The person, legal conservator, family and team indicated that they were not provided any information or the approved provider list. They appear to have been misguided by one particular case manager who did not explain to them that they have options. Neglecting clear team communication is not in the best interests of the people being served by the Medicaid ABI Waiver Program. No options were given to this person and his team. As I am sure you know, person-centered planning is an ongoing problem-solving process used to help people with disabilities plan for their future. In person-centered planning, groups of people focus on an individual and that person's vision of what they would like to do in the future. This "person-centered" team meets to identify opportunities for the focus person to develop personal relationships, participate in their community, increase control over their own lives, and develop the skills and abilities needed to achieve these goals. Person-centered planning depends on the commitment of a team of individuals who care about the focus person. These individuals take action to ensure that the strategies discussed in transitions are implemented. Case managers taking control over the entire process without the person, legal conservator, family and their team involvement is the opposite of person-centered planning. Withholding information from the PERSON, legal conservator, family and or their team undermines person-centered planning. We feel it is important for DSS to recognize the actions and/or lack of actions from this CCCi care manager. This type of neglect should not be allowed by DSS as it undermines the State's ethics and commitment to people recovering within the community on the Medicaid ABI Waiver Program. As you are aware this is not the first time ABI Resources has reported receiving a call from a person, family and or conservator expressing that they were not given options and were directed as to where they will receive services. This type of system has been in place for far too long.
In regard to housing, no person, family and or conservator that has reached out to ABI Resources resides in a home owned by Mindscape. ABI Resources understands that people receiving services from the ABI Waiver Program in addition to housing owned by the same agency are in many ways entrapping people. Individuals and conservators fear losing their services as well as their home if they wish to change services or report any concerns, abuse or neglect. We are concerned that people are indeed trapped and have not been protected as much as they should be. For these reasons, ABI Resources does not and will not own the homes of people receiving services from us.
As for vocational services under the ABI Waiver Program and the people receiving services from Mindscape. Every client receiving supported employment will no longer have a job as a result of Mindscape closing. These people were being paid by Mindscape while the agency was also providing ABI Waiver services for them. If any agency providing ABI Services for a client is also paying them, this is a major conflict of interest and poses an ethical dilemma. People in this situation that wish to change service providers are trapped by fear of losing their job that they rely on to pay for food and housing. Fear from this type of unbalanced relationship may also prevent reporting of abuse and neglect. A system such as this seems unethical as well as a violation of the rights of the people being served. We are concerned that some case managers, currently or in the past, may direct people to agencies that employ and pay the clients while getting paid by the Medicaid ABI Waiver to provide services for the very same client. It is extremely concerning that this has been allowed. For these reasons, ABI Resources does not and will not employ the people we provide services for.
Finally, as it pertains to your statement "it is imperative that the care managers lead the process, without outside influence from providers". That statement is precisely the reason why some care managers appear confused about the definition of person-centered care and planning. The Medicaid ABI Waiver Program is a person-centered community-based recovery program. Person centered care and planning, by definition, is led by the person along with the assistance of their team, not exclusively by the case manager. As a normal course of business, when people and families reach out to us for services, we meet with them. If they wish for us to provide services for them, we send a group email request to the case manager, current agency, CBT, and family to setup a transition meeting. Some case managers may not have anticipated people, families and conservators searching for and reaching out to ABI Resources for services; but they do, all the time. These people and families are often confused and upset when they discover that they were not given options. We agree, DSS should closely monitor each transition to new providers to ensure that case managers are clearly communicating options and not intentionally or unintentionally misleading people or dictating service providers. Both the family that recently contacted us and their attorney expressed to us that they had spoken with other people who were also directed "without options" to providers as well. Case managers that seem to neglect providing important information and options cause mistrust in themselves and in the agency providers they are referring people to. People that are already losing their agency provider, job, paycheck and home should not be further burdened or harmed with mistrust too.
Thank you,
ABI Resources and David Medeiros CBIS
Phone and fax numbers and the confidentiality footer are left out.
David's report at the time. The family's situation is not independently verified here, and nothing in this copy identifies the family.
Privacy-cleaned copy prepared Nov 2026. Names of people who receive services, their families, towns, health details, phone numbers and home addresses are removed and marked [removed]. The original is kept privately.