{"agency": "CMS", "attachments": [{"bytes": null, "classification": "attachment sent by David", "delivery": "NOT YET EXPORTED (held)", "downloadUrl": null, "exportIndex": 1, "file": "022720267094 Inbox - ABI RESOURCES 860 942-0365 - Outlook.pdf", "hashScope": "not yet exported", "originalSha256": "UNKNOWN", "requestId": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "sha256_16": "UNKNOWN", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}, {"bytes": null, "classification": "attachment sent by David", "delivery": "NOT YET EXPORTED (held)", "downloadUrl": null, "exportIndex": 2, "file": "No Records Response Letter -Medeiros-022720267094.pdf", "hashScope": "not yet exported", "originalSha256": "UNKNOWN", "requestId": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "sha256_16": "UNKNOWN", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}, {"bytes": null, "classification": "attachment sent by David", "delivery": "NOT YET EXPORTED (held)", "downloadUrl": null, "exportIndex": 3, "file": "FOIA 022720267094 No Records Response Escalation David Medeiros 2026 03 20.pdf", "hashScope": "not yet exported", "originalSha256": "UNKNOWN", "requestId": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "sha256_16": "UNKNOWN", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}, {"bytes": null, "classification": "attachment sent by David", "delivery": "NOT YET EXPORTED (held)", "downloadUrl": null, "exportIndex": 4, "file": "FOIA 022720267094 No Records Response Escalation David Medeiros 2026 03 20.docx", "hashScope": "not yet exported", "originalSha256": "UNKNOWN", "requestId": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "sha256_16": "UNKNOWN", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}, {"bytes": null, "classification": "attachment sent by David", "delivery": "NOT YET EXPORTED (held)", "downloadUrl": null, "exportIndex": 5, "file": "Outlook-fpd1q5s3.png", "hashScope": "not yet exported", "originalSha256": "UNKNOWN", "requestId": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "sha256_16": "UNKNOWN", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}], "channel": "email from [David Medeiros email removed]", "first_date": "2026-03-20", "lane": "FED - CMS", "last_date": "2026-03-20", "letterId": "L170", "level": "FEDERAL", "messages": [{"direction": "office reply", "file": null, "from": "kimberly.barbour@cms.hhs.gov", "quoted": "", "subject": "FOIA-022720267094", "text": "[Reply from: CMS] Good afternoon,\n\nPlease see attachment regarding your FOIA request.\n\nThank You,\n\nKimberly Barbour\n\nGovernment Information Specialist\n\nDivision of FOIA Analysis - C\n\nOffice of Strategic Operations and Regulatory Affairs (OSORA)\n\nCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services", "text_status": "FULL TEXT - privacy-masked under David's Nov 11 2026 rules", "to": "David Medeiros", "when": "2026-03-17 17:16:32"}, {"direction": "David sent", "file": null, "from": "David Medeiros ([David Medeiros email removed])", "quoted": "From: Barbour, Kimberly (CMS/OSORA) <kimberly.barbour@cms.hhs.gov>\nSent: Tuesday, March 17, 2026 1:15 PM\nTo: [David Medeiros email removed] <[David Medeiros email removed]>\nSubject: FOIA-022720267094\n\nGood afternoon,\n\nPlease see attachment regarding your FOIA request.\n\nThank You,\n\nKimberly Barbour\n\nGovernment Information Specialist\n\nDivision of FOIA Analysis - C\n\nOffice of Strategic Operations and Regulatory Affairs (OSORA)\n\nCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services", "subject": "Re: FOIA-022720267094", "text": "Request for Immediate Escalation and Corrective Action FOIA Control No. 022720267094 (PIN [withheld])\n\nGood afternoon Ms. Barbour,\n\nRe: FOIA Control Number 022720267094 (PIN [withheld]) Response Letter dated March 17, 2026 Requester: David Medeiros\n\nI am responding to the “No Records” determination signed by Director Emmett Nicholson. Due to my traumatic brain injury (TBI), I am unable to engage in phone calls, appeals, or any multi-step administrative process. This email constitutes my complete and final response and formal request for immediate escalation and corrective action.\n\nThe “No Records” finding is factually impossible and violates FOIA. Ability Beyond (formerly Ability Beyond Disability, Inc., EIN 06-0776594) maintains two active NPIs that are created, assigned, and maintained by CMS in the National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES):\n\nNPI 1073744991 Residential Treatment Facility, Intellectual/Developmental Disabilities, Bethel, CT (active since 2009)\n\nNPI 1659575660 Intermediate Care Facility for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities, Danbury, CT (active since 2007)\n\nThese exact NPIs are publicly viewable on CMS-derived registries (see npidb.org and npiprofile.com records pulled directly from the official NPPES database). Ability Beyond is also a longstanding Connecticut Medicaid provider under the ABI/DDS Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) waivers (42 U.S.C. § 1396n(c)), which are jointly funded and overseen by CMS’s Center for Medicaid & CHIP Services (CMCS). The organization serves 200+ individuals, accepts Medicaid, and appears in official Connecticut Department of Developmental Services provider profiles.\n\nA search “reasonably calculated to locate records” (the legal standard under 5 U.S.C. § 552 and CMS FOIA Policy Guide § 30.11) must have located at minimum the NPPES records and waiver-related oversight files. The blanket “zero records” response therefore demonstrates either an unreasonably narrow or defective search protocol, or the improper withholding/non-indexing of records that are indisputably in CMS custody.\n\nImmediate Action Requested (No Further Steps Required from Me)\n\nBecause I cannot navigate the normal FOIA appeal process due to my traumatic brain injury (TBI), I respectfully but urgently request that the Division of FOIA Analysis – C take the actions below today and provide written confirmation by email.\n\nImmediately re-conduct a proper search of all CMS components, including but not limited to: NPPES, CMCS waiver monitoring files, regional office correspondence, state survey/certification records, and any Medicaid claims or provider enrollment data related to EIN 06-0776594 and the two NPIs above.\n\nTreat this “No Records” response as a serious compliance anomaly and formally report it upward with a memorandum detailing: (a) my TBI accommodation needs; (b) the public proof that responsive records exist in CMS systems; and (c) the apparent failure of the search standards applied.\n\nPlease report this matter directly to:\n\nThe Secretary of Health & Human Services\n\nThe Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services\n\nThe Chief Operating Officer & Deputy Administrator of CMS\n\nThe HHS Office of Inspector General (for FOIA compliance and potential systemic issues)\n\nThe U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (Disability Rights Section)\n\nCongressional oversight committees with jurisdiction over CMS/HHS/Medicaid:\n\nSenate Committee on Finance\n\nHouse Committee on Energy & Commerce\n\nHouse Committee on Ways & Means\n\nProvide me (via email to [David Medeiros email removed]) with the date of the internal report, the names/titles of the recipients, and any assigned tracking or referral numbers.\n\nForward a copy of this entire email and the original March 17, 2026 response letter to Desiree Gaynor, CMS FOIA Public Liaison, and to the Office of Government Information Services (OGIS) for immediate mediation and oversight.\n\nThis is not a request for discussion or additional hoops. It is a direct demand for the agency to correct its own error and escalate the documented failure to the highest levels of federal leadership, the Department of Justice, and Congress. Failure to do so will be documented as continued non-compliance.\n\nThank you for your immediate attention and for ensuring this is escalated as requested. I look forward to your written confirmation within five (5) business days.\n\nSincerely,\n\nDavid Medeiros\n\n[ABI Resources office address withheld], STE. C\n\nGales Ferry, CT 06335\n\nEmail: [David Medeiros email removed]\n\nFOIA Control No. 022720267094\n\nBest regards,\n\nDavid Medeiros\n\nABI Resources\n\nMedicaid Acquired Brain Injury ABI Waiver Program Provider\n\nHonor all, Be the best.\n\nDavid-Medeiros.com\n\nNOTE: This e-mail may contain sensitive and/or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient (or have received this email in error) please notify the sender immediately and destroy this e-mail. Any unauthorized copying, disclosure, or distribution of the material in this e-mail is strictly forbidden. Under the Privacy Act of 1974, all data of a private nature must be protected from unauthorized disclosure. Rise Above Challenges", "text_status": "FULL TEXT - privacy-masked under David's Nov 11 2026 rules", "to": "desiree.gaynor@cms.hhs.gov; foia_request@cms.hhs.gov; kimberly.barbour@cms.hhs.gov", "when": "2026-03-20 18:53:02"}, {"direction": "office reply", "file": null, "from": "foia_request@cms.hhs.gov", "quoted": "From: ABI RESOURCES 860 942-0365 <[David Medeiros email removed]>\nSent: Friday, March 20, 2026 2:53 PM\nTo: Barbour, Kimberly (CMS/OSORA) <kimberly.barbour@cms.hhs.gov>\nCc: ogis@nara.gov\nSubject: Re: FOIA-022720267094\nImportance: High\n\nRequest for Immediate Escalation and Corrective Action FOIA Control No. 022720267094 (PIN [withheld])\n\nGood afternoon Ms. Barbour,\n\nRe: FOIA Control Number 022720267094 (PIN [withheld]) Response Letter dated March 17, 2026 Requester: David Medeiros\n\nI am responding to the “No Records” determination signed by Director Emmett Nicholson. Due to my traumatic brain injury (TBI), I am unable to engage in phone calls, appeals, or any multi-step administrative process. This email constitutes my complete and final response and formal request for immediate escalation and corrective action.\n\nThe “No Records” finding is factually impossible and violates FOIA. Ability Beyond (formerly Ability Beyond Disability, Inc., EIN 06-0776594) maintains two active NPIs that are created, assigned, and maintained by CMS in the National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES):\n\nNPI 1073744991 Residential Treatment Facility, Intellectual/Developmental Disabilities, Bethel, CT (active since 2009)\n\nNPI 1659575660 Intermediate Care Facility for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities, Danbury, CT (active since 2007)\n\nThese exact NPIs are publicly viewable on CMS-derived registries (see npidb.org and npiprofile.com records pulled directly from the official NPPES database). Ability Beyond is also a longstanding Connecticut Medicaid provider under the ABI/DDS Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) waivers (42 U.S.C. § 1396n(c)), which are jointly funded and overseen by CMS’s Center for Medicaid & CHIP Services (CMCS). The organization serves 200+ individuals, accepts Medicaid, and appears in official Connecticut Department of Developmental Services provider profiles.\n\nA search “reasonably calculated to locate records” (the legal standard under 5 U.S.C. § 552 and CMS FOIA Policy Guide § 30.11) must have located at minimum the NPPES records and waiver-related oversight files. The blanket “zero records” response therefore demonstrates either an unreasonably narrow or defective search protocol, or the improper withholding/non-indexing of records that are indisputably in CMS custody.\n\nImmediate Action Requested (No Further Steps Required from Me)\n\nBecause I cannot navigate the normal FOIA appeal process due to my traumatic brain injury (TBI), I respectfully but urgently request that the Division of FOIA Analysis – C take the actions below today and provide written confirmation by email.\n\nImmediately re-conduct a proper search of all CMS components, including but not limited to: NPPES, CMCS waiver monitoring files, regional office correspondence, state survey/certification records, and any Medicaid claims or provider enrollment data related to EIN 06-0776594 and the two NPIs above.\n\nTreat this “No Records” response as a serious compliance anomaly and formally report it upward with a memorandum detailing: (a) my TBI accommodation needs; (b) the public proof that responsive records exist in CMS systems; and (c) the apparent failure of the search standards applied.\n\nPlease report this matter directly to:\n\nThe Secretary of Health & Human Services\n\nThe Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services\n\nThe Chief Operating Officer & Deputy Administrator of CMS\n\nThe HHS Office of Inspector General (for FOIA compliance and potential systemic issues)\n\nThe U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division (Disability Rights Section)\n\nCongressional oversight committees with jurisdiction over CMS/HHS/Medicaid:\n\nSenate Committee on Finance\n\nHouse Committee on Energy & Commerce\n\nHouse Committee on Ways & Means\n\nProvide me (via email to [David Medeiros email removed]) with the date of the internal report, the names/titles of the recipients, and any assigned tracking or referral numbers.\n\nForward a copy of this entire email and the original March 17, 2026 response letter to Desiree Gaynor, CMS FOIA Public Liaison, and to the Office of Government Information Services (OGIS) for immediate mediation and oversight.\n\nThis is not a request for discussion or additional hoops. It is a direct demand for the agency to correct its own error and escalate the documented failure to the highest levels of federal leadership, the Department of Justice, and Congress. Failure to do so will be documented as continued non-compliance.\n\nThank you for your immediate attention and for ensuring this is escalated as requested. I look forward to your written confirmation within five (5) business days.\n\nSincerely,\n\nDavid Medeiros\n\n[ABI Resources office address withheld], STE. C\n\nGales Ferry, CT 06335\n\nEmail: [David Medeiros email removed]\n\nFOIA Control No. 022720267094\n\nBest regards,\n\nDavid Medeiros\n\nABI Resources\n\nMedicaid Acquired Brain Injury ABI Waiver Program Provider\n\nHonor all, Be the best.\n\nDavid-Medeiros.com\n\nNOTE: This e-mail may contain sensitive and/or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient (or have received this email in error) please notify the sender immediately and destroy this e-mail. Any unauthorized copying, disclosure, or distribution of the material in this e-mail is strictly forbidden. Under the Privacy Act of 1974, all data of a private nature must be protected from unauthorized disclosure. Rise Above Challenges\n\nFrom: Barbour, Kimberly (CMS/OSORA) <kimberly.barbour@cms.hhs.gov>\nSent: Tuesday, March 17, 2026 1:15 PM\nTo: [David Medeiros email removed] <[David Medeiros email removed]>\nSubject: FOIA-022720267094\n\nGood afternoon,\n\nPlease see attachment regarding your FOIA request.\n\nThank You,\n\nKimberly Barbour\n\nGovernment Information Specialist\n\nDivision of FOIA Analysis - C\n\nOffice of Strategic Operations and Regulatory Affairs (OSORA)\n\nCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services", "subject": "RE: FOIA-022720267094", "text": "[Reply from: CMS] Good morning,\n\nIn response to your email below, I want to let you know that your request has been forwarded for additional record search. When I receive a response I will let you know.\n\nThank you,\n\nKim", "text_status": "FULL TEXT - privacy-masked under David's Nov 11 2026 rules", "to": "David Medeiros", "when": "2026-03-31 15:19:37"}], "muckrock_id": null, "paperTrail": {"adaWordEmails": 1, "deletedWithoutBeingReadEmails": 0, "deliveryProofByAddress": "NO BOUNCE:3", "emailsSent": 1, "escalationWordEmails": 1, "laterNoRecords": "2026-06-10 from emmett.nicholson@cms.hhs.gov", "officeReplies": 2, "receipts": 6, "reportFileEmails": 0, "rules": "receipt is not action; no bounce is not proof of delivery; after, never because; program counts"}, "publicationDate": "2026-11-11", "request_key": "EM-20260320-CMS-4f7cca", "route": "/foia/email/em-20260320-cms-4f7cca/", "routeStatus": "Published full-text request record", "siteNow": "nothing", "siteStatus20261110": "NO", "sourceRecordSha256": "a1512fa7d58868924e385dcda871a753afbcd1123d5d7912a4791688acc02e06", "sourceSearchUrl": null, "sourceSnapshotDate": "2026-11-11", "title": "Re: FOIA-022720267094", "trackingIdsAsWritten": ["022720267094"]}